Coming out of my cage like Seamus Heaney*

*This is an obscure joke that nobody except ~lissajous will understand, and I apologise. Seamus Heaney is not otherwise referred to in this post.

So, turns out I still have many Dreamwidth posts in various states of completion, mostly because my idea of a post is “write two thousand words about a handful of things that are vaguely related and then attempt to tie it all together neatly at the end” like I’m rector of the parish or some shit. At the same time I have Things I Want To Say About Fandom, which are much shorter, but which I also don’t post because I don’t think they’re high-effort enough. What I need to do is bite the bullet and start wading through the drafts I have, while also permitting myself the indulgence of making the odd contribution that isn’t in the length and format of an undergraduate essay. In this post I’m going to attempt to do both those things at once by filling in A Meme Most People Did Weeks Ago, while also making the occasional (occasionally lengthy) digression about other fandom-related stuff that’s been on my mind recently.

A Meme Most People Did Weeks Ago

1. How long have you been in fandom?

When I was at the stage in my life that required me to write those undergraduate essays, my favourite tutor once told me every essay question contains a supposition that needs to be taken apart. I think the flaw in the current question is clear enough, as it relates to something people opine about on DW frequently: what does being “in fandom” really mean? A lot of people tend to see it as requiring interaction with other fans, although I think my definition is looser than that: there are things I get obsessive about and suddenly I find myself needing to consume, create, and curate all possible content. The first time that happened that I remember, I was five, and I’ve remained fannish about a succession of things ever since, although there have been periods when that hasn’t extended to writing fic or similarly producing stuff.

2. Which fandoms are you in now?

So, this is where I talk about FF16 fandom! I think I was a bit premature before when I said everyone had moved on from it extremely quickly, because we were in that intermediate period where some people had finished the game and others were probably very invested but were trying to avoid spoilers, and now it seems like the fandom is settling down and solidifying a bit. I mean, there’s a kinkmeme now (hard mode: guess which prompts are mine; non-hard mode: I’m very vanilla), so that means it’s the cool new thing, right?

I mentioned before how weird it is to be in a new and popular fandom, particularly in that there’s an active Discord server not merely for the fandom itself but specifically for the main ship involving my fave. There are actually now two of those servers. I joined the second one because I couldn’t bear the thought of people saying things about Dion without being able to eavesdrop, but I don’t see a huge amount of point in its existence, tbh. The servers are:

a. The main server with nearly 300 members now. People talk about other ships, but there are dedicated threads for those now so it’s easy to ignore. A big emphasis on “everyone’s opinion is valid”, which is good, but that extends to banning discourse about other ships and even banning mentions of the fact that Rival Shippers have some of us blocked on twixtter (even me, and I never use that platform to express an individual thought, honest guv!). Even a message saying that “our ship” now has more fics on (boo, hiss) AO3 than the main canon couple was deleted because (paraphrasing) “some people don’t look at stats”. I do however appreciate the mod’s insistence that people not mention the server to the VAs … although I’m also sure Stewart Clarke has some awareness of the server’s existence … he’s like, the chief shitposter of the Dion fandom [endgame spoilers @ link], who also happens to be able to do the voice, lol.

b. The small “archive server” that currently has under 20 members. From what I was led to believe, this was meant for posting fan content without going into the long chains of discussion that always happen on the other server, and was also meant to be a more, er, drama-positive space (one of the people who set it up has flounced twice from the other server already and it hasn’t even been a month). But there still seems to be a lot of discussion (although at least it’s in dedicated channels) and none of it is drama (boo, what am I here for if not rubbernecking), and also, nobody posts any commentary on the stuff they “archive” so it’s completely unsearchable. (Also I’m irrationally annoyed by Mr Drama because he posted a load of links to fics on AO3 and then said he’d linked “every [ship]-centric fic”, as if that particular website is the only place people might deign to post it … this is a game I very much have skin in as I’ve posted D/T fics to a non-AO3 location so I’m incapable of being objective, but …)

Something that annoys me about people in both servers is the whole “I’m a fandom elder” mentality. Like, I’m 30 and I don’t consider myself to be “old” in fandom terms at all. Somebody made a remark about top/bottom discourse having been tiring “in the nineties”, and … mate, you’re thirty-two years old, I guarantee you were not discussing this in the nineties. The main mod of the big server is 26 and has taken to referring to herself as everyone’s mother, which I just can’t get on board with. There’s also at least one person aged under 18 in the larger server, which is a bit yikes, but they haven’t said anything for a while, so maybe they’ve … ahaha I’m gonna make the joke, I’m gonna do it … maybe they’ve gone back to playing Fortnite.

3. Do you create transformative works?

Yes.

4. What was your first fandom?

The live-action version of 101 Dalmatians, because I was five and had no taste. Apparently prior to this I was “obsessed” with Thomas the Tank Engine, but the dogs are the first thing I have records of having written fic for.

5. How often has fic made you cry?

Never. I very rarely cry these days, especially for media-related reasons. I didn’t even cry playing FFX: the closest I got was the lake scene on my second playthrough. I’ve been looking for an excuse to talk about the moments where I got misty-eyed in FF16, so here they are:

late-game spoilers
  • Byron and Clive’s reunion, when Byron has a vision of fifteen-year-old Clive and is so overcome by emotion that he literally falls to his knees.
  • Wade’s goodbye to Clive at the end of the final Wade-related sidequest. I just really love Wade!! Points at icon enthusiastically!!
  • The line on Vivian’s chart between Clive and Jill saying “in love”. Like with the FFX lake scene, I’m always … secretly enamoured with the canon het couple, lol.

While I love both Auron and Dion probably more than all other characters in their respective games put together, nothing related to either of them has ever made me cry. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

6. Rec a fic that you love!

I’m just gorging myself on Dion-centric fics these days.

FF16 late-game spoilers

I’m not usually a fan of the “Dion and Terence adopt Kihel” take, although ~lavendre’s recent fic  T   ☉   ♂  7k+ kind of changed my mind on that? It’s gorgeous, anyway.

7. Who’s your ult OTP?

Auron/Braska, of course.

FF16 spoilers up to gaining Titan’s powers

… I did genuinely worry that Dion/Terence might take over, but there’s no contest. That said, I enjoy having two ships that currently loom large in my consciousness because of the differences between them: A/B is the “tragic because it’s probably unrequited and at least one of them dies” pairing, D/T is the “definitely requited and it’s not actually all that clear whether either of them dies” pairing. The similarities are probably why I like both, but the differences mean they’re both really appealing to think about for different reasons. Like, if I want to imagine a scenario that’s angsty because of miscommunication and uncertainty, give me A/B, but if I want two boys who are in love and know they are, it’s D/T. If it’s “yep, at least one of us is going to die at a specific point in time”, it’s A/B, but if it’s more of a “we may indeed die tragically at any moment, who knows” … etc.

8. Share a pic that would convince someone to fall for your current fandom!

Torgal is best boy. He is cute and also enormous.

9. Have you ever met a fandom friend IRL?

I went on holiday for two weeks with ficster28 in 2014. We hadn’t met before IRL, although we went to the same university (and the following year we ended up having tutorials together, in an extremely niche subject). We actually met through Tumblr, rather than through fandom specifically, although that definitely counts; at the time, she was big into Dan and Phil, although my Dan and Phil phase ended up being a couple of years later (more on that, in excruciating detail, below).

We didn’t really stay in touch after 2015, probably partly because it was a dodgy mental health time for both of us and we were two of the only three people taking this stupid exam on weird poetry written by medieval incels (disclaimer: I am not a literary scholar and this is probably a misrepresentation); I remember Gina noting that she was terrible at keeping friends once, and so am I, so when you have that in both directions it’s a recipe for disaster. Gina recently posted a new fic and I wondered about leaving a creepy comment (as I did a few years ago before noping out and deleting mine after she replied because I thought she was going to unwittingly doxx me), but it was a Harry Potter fic and I just couldn’t bring myself to.

10. What’s the last fandom merch or craft you got?

Ha, I very recently got myself an official Final Fantasy X wallet. It’s actually a designer wallet that I had to get imported from Japan via a proxy service, so it cost, er, quite a bit more than I’d normally spend on that sort of thing, but I’d been wanting a new one for a while because my previous one wasn’t androgynous enough to allow me to ✨live my truth✨, so this appeared at the right moment.

I’ve restrained myself from ordering any FF16 stuff from Japan, although in my weaker moments I’ve caught myself staring at the Dion coaster being resold for like 75 quid on eBay, sigh … as for the recently published artbook, I’m content to wait for the English edition unless someone tells me there are Wade pictures. If that’s the case I’ll just … walk to Japan and wrest it from the hands of an unsuspecting salesperson.

This is also the time to note that while I haven’t pre-ordered the Dion action figure, I’m definitely going to get it when it’s released. I have never been an action figure person before … and yet! I have never been remotely interested in blond men … and yet!! [ETA: I subsequently remembered the last statement was untrue.]

11. Rare pairs, big ships, or gen?

Um, tragic master/servant? Sad brown-eyed men?

12. Are you multi-fandom or mono-fannish?

Final Fantasy.

13. When did you last travel for a con, concert, fanmeet, or cupsleeve event?

Like everyone who filled this in before, I have no idea what a cupsleeve event is. It was April for Final Symphony, but my mind is more occupied by the fact that we’re going to Kupocon in London next month. I’m still not sure whether I made a good decision regarding this because the new semester starts the day after we get back and student enrolment is always, as one of my colleagues put it last year, “a shitstorm”, but Yuna’s VA is going to be there and I think that’s what sealed the deal for me.

On that note, here’s an image from one of my four ongoing largescale FFX-related projects, and fortunately the only one with a deadline:

14. How did you get into your current fandom?

Ok so here’s the story of how I got into Final Fantasy. It’s long and I’m sorry. It’s also sort of about my career (somewhat embarrassingly), and also about three people who have been important in my life: two who I regret losing contact with, and one who, as I write this particular sentence, is sleeping in bed next to me. ☺

(subcut for length because this is almost two thousand words long I’m Sorry)

When I was eight, I made a friend who now goes by the name R online, and was more like me than anyone else I’d met before. We went to different secondary schools a few years later but still hung out a lot, which is pretty remarkable when, as noted above, I’m terrible at keeping friends. When we were about thirteen, we began hanging out on the internet a lot. R’s dad was actually a web developer, back in the noughties when I guess people just wrote raw HTML all the time (??), and R knew a lot about computers and internet culture, and in tandem with this developed an intense obsession with FF7 and particularly Sephiroth. This was not long after Advent Children had been released.

I didn’t have a PlayStation and was never really interested enough to find out anything about FF7 myself, but for a few months, R talked about it so much that I osmosed a few things. We used to listen to the Piano Collections and particularly One-Winged Angel, and I downloaded that track from some dodgy website and kept it in my iTunes and succession of iPods for years afterwards. (Tangent: I was really into Apple products for a while! My dad bought himself an iMac in 2001, quickly realised it was incompatible with most stuff he needed for work, and then passed it on to me; I had a great time. Mac OS X 10.1 is an Experience. I continued to be mostly a Mac user until 2018 at which point I became a FOSS neckbeard.)

I moved away for university and gradually fell out of touch with R afterwards (possibly the biggest regret of my life? but what can you do), and embarked upon my normie era: made a couple of very face-value friends, was mostly into choral singing (still am, but more … critically?), had a big normie boyfriend for a short time (the fact that we were mostly long-distance probably prolonged that time, tbh; also I can’t believe I went out with someone several inches taller than me! why would anyone do that), quite possibly didn’t develop any weird fandom obsessions at all for two or three years. I even considered myself a straight woman for a while, which is baffling. During this period, though, I met the above ficster28 and was drawn back into that life by … jealousy, I guess? Nothing but healthy emotions here.

So Gina is one of those people who has two separate online personalities. I kind of am too, in that I have a professional website and used to use twitxter for work, under my legal name, and then I also have my fandom persona on the Dreamwidth and on my website, where I try not to make it obvious which of the eight billion people on this earth is actually me. Gina makes the split in a different place: she’s content to associate most fandom stuff with her offline identity, but her RPF side is completely separate from that, which I guess is fair enough when all your family know your Tumblr URL. I met Gina through her main online identity (where she goes by her legal name), and didn’t come upon the Gina side of her until after our holiday together, when I was fascinated to find that there was a whole swathe of stuff I hadn’t been aware of before (including a fic she wrote in which the two of us appear  G   ♂  9k+). Most of it related to Dan and Phil; I was like ok, whatever.

Then about eighteen months later (let me pause here both to apologise and to promise this is still relevant to Final Fantasy), I was on Gina’s Tumblr and found myself getting kind of interested in Dan and Phil. I had been into much more problematic RPF previously (looking at you, coalition government) and had no qualms about getting invested in these lads, particularly when I found out about all the secrets and drama about a certain deleted video. At this time a new Dan and Phil forum was being set up and I was intrigued by the audacity of its members in starting a forum in 2016. I joined and became pretty active for a while. At that point in my life I was doing a master’s degree and was quite lonely, and my daily schedule soon became the following: morning: engage with Dan and Phil content; afternoon: write my thesis.

I had many years’ worth of Dan and Phil videos to catch up on, and noticed some familiar music in their early material: back in the day, they used to use a lot of music from FF7. The soundtrack of the infamous deleted video used Tifa’s Theme, and I had an “I know you” moment (kind of similar to that moment in FF16 where a certain Dominant is visited in his tent by … ok I’ll stop). After that I sought out the rest of the FF7 soundtrack, and came across the sheet music for the Piano Collections, and as soon as I attempted to play One-Winged Angel, I was like, oh. It’s this. It’s my childhood. My implicitly weebish teenage years that I suppressed! They’re back!

At around that time, after some uncertainty about my future, I discovered I’d be moving to the city in which I now live (the worst-kept secret on this journal, lol, I might as well just post my address at this point). I looked online to see if there were any orchestras I might join once I got here, and one of the top results on Google was for an orchestra that specialised in the music of video games. At this point in my life, I wasn’t much of a gamer beyond having occasionally borrowed R’s Pokémon games years earlier and going on Kongregate a lot as an undergraduate, but I knew about the FF7 soundtrack and therefore I knew game music was good.

It took about a year after I moved here for me to actually join the orchestra, because how do socialise, but once I did so I found that, shockingly, there were more people like me in the world, weird awkward nerds in their (then) early twenties. The orchestra itself turned out to be … not that good and pretty badly run, and there was eventually a lot of Drama, but they were fun people to hang out with, and back in the pre-Drama days we used to go for a drink after rehearsals. There was this … idk, this nerdy young IT man, haha, who lived in the same direction as me so we used to walk home together afterwards. I sometimes saw him on his way to work in the mornings and was like “oh! it’s my friend!”. At the time I was living in my own after a year of Social Anxiety Houseshare, and loved it. Anyway … not what this story is about, but a couple of months later we eventually got together, with some encouragement from a mutual friend in the orchestra who also got together with another girl in the orchestra at around the same time (they’re engaged now), and, yeah, now there’s this cute creature sleeping beside me!

A lot of the music we played in the orchestra was (often badly) arranged by members of the orchestra itself. I became very into orchestration for a while, and made a few arrangements; some of the pieces on my VGM page were originally written for the orchestra. The first arrangement I did was Tifa’s Theme; the peak of my Dan and Phil phase had passed, but it was a meaningful piece of music for me nonetheless. I then discovered that the original PC release of FF7 had had a MIDI soundtrack, and that this soundtrack was available online, so I started a project to convert all these MIDIs into nice-looking, playable sheet music (god, I started this in … 2017? and I still consider it an ongoing project … I’m actually really near the end, but One-Winged Angel is intimidating enough for me not to have touched it for several years). Around the time ~lissajous and I got together, he bought himself a Nintendo Switch, and a year later when we moved in together I at last experienced the joy of being A Console Gamer. A year or so after that, I discovered FF7 was available on the Switch, and it was pretty clear that I had to play it after all these years of its being an important thing in my life.

I had no idea what was going on. I got maybe a third of the way through the game, realised I lacked most of the equipment and materia that would have made it somewhat playable, and then started following a walkthrough to the letter. Even though I lost my free will in the process, I ended up pretty much 100%ing the game because it was unlike any experience I’d had before. At this point it was early 2020, and I was finishing my PhD with a huge amount of uncertainty about what was coming next, especially given that it was, as stated, early 2020. I finished FF7 and then threw myself into playing Crisis Core on an emulator on my phone, probably as a coping mechanism. I briefly made a terrible career decision and moved to England, only to find the following day that there was an (at the time temporary) post available at the university I’d just left, and because of the vagaries of the recruitment process it was mine if I was happy enough to leave my new non-academic and probably slightly dodgy job in a new city where I didn’t know anyone. So obviously I accepted that right away.

Anyway, everything was very traumatic but fortunately I’d bought myself the GBA version of FF6 just before moving and consoled myself by playing it constantly on my Nintendo DS, and writing fic for the first time after a three-year break. I was amazed to find that FF6 took an even more vicelike grip on me than FF7 had. Everything about it was absolutely sublime. Like with FF7, I barely knew what I was doing and ended up gluing myself to a walkthrough halfway through, but this thing took hold of my brain for several months (and then I met FFX … they just get better!!).

When I returned home, I was adamant that I now needed to play every other Final Fantasy game in existence. That’s something I’m still working on, but … yeah, in conclusion, I hope this story has demonstrated that although I didn’t start playing these games until my mid-twenties, they mean an indescribably huge amount to me! Crikey. If you read all that … sorry again. How embarrassing.

15. What’s your favorite trope?

I really like “accidentally falling asleep on each other”. I also like this very specific ship dynamic that I may have just invented:

A: secretly pining for B and will do absolutely anything B asks, aware that B is having a Hard Time and doesn’t want to make it worse for them by confessing;
B: deeply troubled, relies on A for comfort to an extent that involves a lot of physical touching and sometimes kissing, but hasn’t paused for a moment to consider that they might actually be in love with A, and even after a third party points it out to them, is too mentally fucked up to come to any definite conclusion.

The “A” and “B” in that description are obviously not coincidental.

16. What are 3 tags that will make you click no matter what?

Final Fantasy X Series, Dion Lesage, Wade (Final Fantasy XVI).

17. Fav fest you’ve prompted/read/written for?

Semi-serious answer: /ffprompts, obviously. It is so great seeing various FF fics pop up on my reading page, and even more great seeing people commenting on each other’s stuff. It’s like a prompt comm where I’m interested in all the fills. (girl eating from all the different plates meme)

18. Share an upcoming fest you’re excited about!

I’m hoping to be similarly productive in /no_true_pair to last year, having signed up with all my FF16 faves (a few whose names end in “-on”, and miraculously, a few whose don’t)! I keep thinking I won’t manage it because of the aforementioned beginning of the semester, but then I remember the semester also started last September and I seemed to get on ok.

19. What’s your favorite episode, song, moment, etc. from your current fandom?

FF16 spoilers up to gaining Bahamut’s powers [but not actually Dion-related!]

“IS THIS THE CHILD YOU MADE WITH THE EMPEROR?!”

(Ben Starr delivers his lines so well and I found this to be a standout example!)

Want to respond to this? Want to see other people’s responses?